If Snowden Had Simply Revealed Presence of NSA Programs, He’d Definitely Be A Whistleblower; But He Took Four Laptops With Top Secret Information to Chinese Territory, and Then Russia: He Went There to Sell the Information in Exchange for Money and Protection

I’ve gotten some feedback from my last post suggesting that we offer to return convicted arms dealer Victor Bout to Russia, in exchange for their turning Snowden over to the FBI, and I should probably clarify where I stand on his acts.

I’m glad he revealed the existence of the NSA monitoring program; that’s the first step in getting an under-the-radar program under some kind of positive control.  Yes, it’s probably caused irreversible damage to the efforts of our security agencies to monitor what groups like al-Qaeda are plotting next.

That damage aside, Snowden went from simple whistleblowing to something else when he went to Hong Kong with classified materials and began shopping around for a country to take him in.   We don’t know if he talked to China’s intelligence services while he was in Hong Kong.  We also don’t know if he talked to Russia’s intelligence service about the materials in his possession, or if he even has the material anymore.

We need to bring him in, with the stolen material he took, and question him to figure out if he deserves whistleblower protection, or if he needs to be charged with treason and similar kinds of crimes.  I think it falls into the “treason” column myself.  But we can’t do that until someone detains him and turns him over.

He needs to to return to the U.S., involuntarily if necessary, attorney up, and have his day in court.